Hi Everybody, I’m hoping I can get some advice. I plan on purchasing a new Shopbot machine in the near future as an early pre-retirement gift to myself. However, I’m having a hard time deciding exactly what machine to purchase and I’m hoping I can get some help from the Shopbot forum…
First of all, let me say I’m am completely impressed with the Shopbot community. I've been pouring through this forum. You guys combine technical knowledge, trade skill and artistry to a fascinating level. I’m constantly in awe of the beautiful projects that you are producing. I have a fair amount of woodworking experience, but I have a lot to learn to even come close to the people in this forum.
I have narrowed my choice of machines between the Shopbot Desktop Max (which was just announced to the people on the waiting list) or the PRS Standard 96-48 full size machine. I know a lot of people recommend going as big as you can afford – either machine is in the budget along with the peripheral equipment that I will need. The struggle I’m having is not price, but precision. I plan on using the machine for wood engravings/relief work, some plaques and maybe some smaller furniture. The larger size of the 96-48 would be nice for getting into larger work eventually (for fun, not so much for revenue). However, I’m concerned about what I will be losing with regard to the extra precision of the desktop unit. I considered the Buddy too, but I have room for the full size.
I’ve been a mechanical engineer for +30 years with CAD experience the whole time. So I get the difference in design between the desktop ball screw drives and the full size rack / pinion – and the corresponding effects on repeatability/accuracy. When I posed the question to Shopbot, I was told verbally there is a difference – the full size machine is good to 0.016” (not as good as the website says for some reason) and the desktop is 0.002”. The person I talked to said that the resulting engravings would be “rougher” on the full size and I would not be able to do lettering less than ½”. But I realize that feeds/speeds/tooling/maintenance has a role too.
I know this is incredibly difficult to articulate, but can anybody tell me some of the difference in quality I will get between the machines for producing plaques / engravings ? I see some incredibly detailed work coming off the Buddy’s and the Full Size machines – so I’m having trouble visualizing under what circumstances or projects the desktop might do better than the full size unit. To be honest, I really want to buy the full size for the extra capacity.
Sorry about the novel, thanks for any advice !