Mitch, Mitch, Mitch,
You had me worried with #3. :-)
Zach,
I chose to buy ShopBot because of this forum and the indexer and have never, ever regretted it. The indexer is an incredible tool capable of many things that you just can't do on a 3 axis machine.
Go for it! I did and haven't looked back. Now I'm making some rather cool "round" stuff as well.